The utility of data-driven feature selection: Re: Chu et al. 2012
نویسندگان
چکیده
The recent Chu et al. (2012) manuscript discusses two key findings regarding feature selection (FS): (1) data driven FS was no better than using whole brain voxel data and (2) a priori biological knowledge was effective to guide FS. Use of FS is highly relevant in neuroimaging-based machine learning, as the number of attributes can greatly exceed the number of exemplars. We strongly endorse their demonstration of both of these findings, and we provide additional important practical and theoretical arguments as to why, in their case, the data-driven FS methods they implemented did not result in improved accuracy. Further, we emphasize that the data-driven FS methods they tested performed approximately as well as the all-voxel case. We discuss why a sparse model may be favored over a complex one with similar performance. We caution readers that the findings in the Chu et al. report should not be generalized to all data-driven FS methods.
منابع مشابه
Applying Feature-Selection Algorithm to Predict Landslide in the Southwest of Iran
Extended abstract 1- INTRODUCTION Nowadays people have an increased sensitivity towards landslides especially in mountainous areas using change in the land use and the expansion of communication networks (Gvrsysky et al., 2006). In the twentieth century, Asia has allocated the highest incident of landslides (220 landslides). Latin America has had the highest number of casualties (more than 2,...
متن کاملCombination of Feature Selection and Learning Methods for IoT Data Fusion
In this paper, we propose five data fusion schemes for the Internet of Things (IoT) scenario,which are Relief and Perceptron (Re-P), Relief and Genetic Algorithm Particle Swarm Optimization (Re-GAPSO), Genetic Algorithm and Artificial Neural Network (GA-ANN), Rough and Perceptron (Ro-P)and Rough and GAPSO (Ro-GAPSO). All the schemes consist of four stages, including preprocessingthe data set ba...
متن کاملFactors Affecting Decision Making of Households Living in the Deprived Provinces to Enter Health Market
Extended Abstract Introduction: Providing the necessary ground for economic growth and development is one of the main goals of policymakers, experts and managers of all governments, especially in developing countries, such as Iran. In this regard, firstly, factors necessary for economic growth and development should be identified and then conditions should be prepared for acceleration of growt...
متن کاملFactors Affecting Decision Making of Households Living in the Deprived Provinces to Enter Health Market
Extended Abstract Introduction: Providing the necessary ground for economic growth and development is one of the main goals of policymakers, experts and managers of all governments, especially in developing countries, such as Iran. In this regard, firstly, factors necessary for economic growth and development should be identified and then conditions should be prepared for acceleration of growt...
متن کاملA Common Weight Data Envelopment Analysis Approach for Material Selection
Material selection is one of the major problems in manufacturing environments since the improper selected material may lead to fail in the production processes and result in customer dissatisfaction and cost inefficiency. Every material has different properties which should be considered as major criteria during the material selection procedure. Selection criteria could be quantitative or quali...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- NeuroImage
دوره 84 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2014